 |
Health Psychology Home PagePapers written by students providing scientific reviews of topics related to health and well being |
| Search | Home | Weight Loss | Alternative Therapy | Supplements | Eating Disorders | Fitness | Links | Self-Assessment | About this Page | |
The
Atkins Diet...Is it all its cracked up to be?
By Carrie
Paddock
Introduction
Hold
everything but the meat...What is the Atkins Diet?
Contradiction:How
does a person get thin living on fatty foods?
Other
Benefits
Dr.
Atkins' Crew on how it works..
What
some ex-Atkins dieters have to say
Not
in favor? Say Pie!
Studies
show...
In
conclusion
References
Introduction
Since
it’s introduction in the middle 1970’s, the Atkins Protein Diet has grown
to be one of the most popular methods of weight loss. It requires
a large amount of self-discipline and dedication but if done properly it
seems that people can lose a tremendous amount of weight in short period
of time. There are also claims that Atkins dieters will experience
other health benefits as well. The Atkins Center for Complementary
Medicine is confident that their diet is the most successful means of weight
loss around as they teach patients to determine their personal sensitivity
to carbohydrates and manage their weight and health for life. They
have successfully treated over 60,000 patients who followed their diet,
which each subject experiencing some of the beneficial health effects as
well. http://www.atkinscenter.com/diet101/htmlYet
other researchers argue that this diet is incredibly bad for the human
body and is not a means of losing weight and especially keeping it off.
http://www.wfla.com/health/272.htm
This
page will discuss the Atkins diet, how it works, and studies for and against
it will be discussed.
Hold everything but the meat...What is the Atkins Diet?
The idea of the Atkins Diet is to cut carbohydrates out of one’s diet in order to lose a significant amount of weight. An Atkins dieter is not to consume starchy foods such as bread, pasta, potatoes, cereal, any foods containing sugar, high sugar fruits and vegetables, and even fruit juices; Thus eliminating many foods one would normally need as a part of the four food groups to stay healthy. A dieter is allowed no more than 30 carbohydrates a day; the equivalent of a few pieces of lettuce or less than one apple, which is drastically less than the suggested servings for fruits and vegetables. An Atkins dieter is restricted to eat only meat and dairy products, including chicken, fish, and milk, and even bacon, eggs, cheese, and butter. In other words, one can live on the most fattening foods, eating all the steak and rib dinners that they want, and still lose weight. http://www.atkinscenter.com/diet101.html
Contradiction: How does a person get thin living on fatty foods?
The Atkins Diet
works in two main ways:
1) Since carbohydrates are the first forms of energy burned in the body,
the body goes into ketosis and learns to burn the fat as energy because
it has no more carbohydrates to use. Ketosis is when there are no glycogen
reserves in the liver so the body breaks down muscle mass in order to make
energy that are necessary for brain function.
2) Because carbohydrates are digested quicker than protein and fat, one
can become hungry soon after eating a huge plate of pasta or huge bowl
of fruit. By eating only protein, one will feel fuller, longer, and
will have less of an urge to snack in between meals. http://www.atkinscenter.com/diet101/html
In addition to losing a good amount of weight, an Atkins dieter may experience improvements in health and overall well being. This diet supposedly improves cholesterol and blood pressure levels, and helps alleviate some problems such as fatigue, irritability, depression, chronic headaches, and some forms of joint and muscle pain. Type 2 diabetics may also see an improvement in their blood lipid profiles therefore having to rely less on their medications to maintain proper health. http://www.atkinscenter.com/diet101.html
Dr. Atkins' “crew" on how it works…
The people at the Atkins Center for Complementary Medicine in New York
have done years of research in order to provide the world with safer and
healthier methods of losing weight. Dr. Atkins and his colleagues
claim that obesity has grown to 33% over the past couple decades proportionately
with carbohydrate intake, death due to heart disease has risen 10%, and
cases of diabetes are growing in near epidemic proportions. The Atkins
Center claims that “All of these conditions are linked not by the amount
of fat in ones diet, but by blood sugar disturbances and insulin disorders
caused by excessive refined carbohydrate consumption.”
http://www.atkinscenter.com/diet101.html
Researchers at the Atkins Center claim that humans rarely use body fat
as energy unless there is restricted carbohydrate consumption. http://www.atkinscenter.com/diet101.html
They say that this restriction will cause anyone to burn body fat as energy
rather than carbohydrates. The researchers claim that the fewer carbohydrates
present, the more sustained the blood sugar level remains throughout the
day because sugar is always metabolized first. Cravings are caused
by blood sugar fluctuations that are aggravated by carbohydrate consumption.
http://www.msn.com By cutting the
carbohydrates, a person’s blood sugar can retain a more even level throughout
the day, therefore he or she will have no cravings and refrain from in-between
meal snacks. Also, diets high in sugar and refined carbohydrates increase
the body’s production of insulin. When insulin levels are high, food
is more quickly turned into body fat in the form of triglycerides, and
high triglyceride levels are one of the greatest risk factors for heart
disease. By using the fat cells for energy one is able to cleanse the burned
stored fat out of their cells, thus causing the dramatic drop in weight.
http://www4.phys.com/applications/HpyerNews/get/forums/affirm/70.html
One of the questions regarding any diet is whether or not the weight
can be kept of when the diet is complete. The Atkins Center does
say that when one is satisfied with the drop in weight and is ready to
bring carbohydrates back into their daily diet at the previous level.
http://www.atkinscenter.com/diet101.html
What
some ex-Atkins dieters have to say…
“I guess I started it January of 98’ which would have been about 15 months
ago. I’ve lost 55 pounds.” http://www.wfla.com/health/272.htm
“I agree. Atkins works. Got more energy than ever; Losing weight;
15 so far, 6 weeks; Plan on being on till 2000; Goal 50.” http://www.msn.com
“On my regular high carb diet, my cholesterol was 187 and my fasting insulin
was 69.9. I was 285 pounds. That was March 1998, and five months
after starting with Atkins, I weighed 235, my fasting insulin level was
18, and my cholesterol was at 70! I was stronger than ever and never
felt hungry!”
“I lost 20
pounds on the Atkins Diet and 14 months later I have kept 17 off!
It was such an easy way to lose weight and I’ve never had such an easy
time keeping it off. I feel healthy, energetic, and thin!” http://www4.phys.com/applications/HyperNews/get/forums/affirm/70.html
Even though the Atkins Center shows good proof that their diet is a successful
means of weight loss, many researchers oppose it and argue that is a very
unhealthy way of losing weight. The following are brief claims made
about the main arguments on the effectiveness of the diet.
- Some researchers claim that when a person is not taking in an adequate
amount of carbohydrates that they will have a lack of energy, therefore
they will be too lethargic to exercise and ultimately not lose any weight.
http://www.wfla.com/health/272.htm
-Michelle Albers, PhD, RD, who is a Medical Team Nutrition Expert says
that the foods that are eliminated by this diet, especially fruits and
vegetables, are the ones that are proven to help prevent cancer and cardiovascular
disease. http://www.wfla.com/health/272.htm
-Robert J. Bolster, MD argues that the key to losing fat is to get a little
bit of everything. “Eat and work out enough to raise your metabolism
and eat COMPLEX carbohydrates rather than white breads and sugars. Eat
Raisin Bran, vegetables, and fruits over a bagel or pretzels; white breads
and sweets are the worst you can choose.
http://www4.phys.com/applications/HpyerNews/get/forums/affirm/70.html
Heilbronn, Noakes, and Clifton (1999) studied the effects of energy restriction, weight loss, and diet composition on plasma lipids and glucose in patients with Type 2 diabetes. Thirty-five obese patients with type 2 diabetes were placed into one of three low-calorie diets: high carbohydrate, high monounsaturated fat, and high-saturated fat. All subjects were then followed for a 12-week period with weekly tests on weight, blood pressure and blood sugar levels. They found that diet composition did not affect the amount of weight loss, but they did prove that the higher protein diet caused reductions in plasma glucose levels, insulin levels, and blood pressure. When insulin levels are high, the body turns sugars and starches more quickly into trigycerides and therefore causes an increase in appetite. So as stated by the Atkins Center, this studied proved that a higher protein diet will help in the suppression of in between meal cravings. In addition, this study helped prove that blood pressure can be lowered with a higher protein diet which was also one of the supposed benefits of the Atkins Diet.
Whitehead, McNeill, and Smith (1996) studied the effect of protein in energy expenditure when the body is at rest. They used four different groups of subjects each with a different diet varying with fat, carbohydrates, and protein. The participants were of varying weight and age between 18-67. The weight of the subjects in the fasting state was measured every seven days and skinfold thickness was used at different intervals to determine percentage of body fat. Sleeping metabolic rate (SMR) was also measured for six hours every night. The researchers found that all groups studied had a decrease in overall energy expenditure and sleeping metabolic rate no matter what their diet was, but the decrease was much less in the group with a high-protein diet. This shows that the higher consumption of protein over carbohydrates and fats does increase metabolism even when the body is at rest. Therefore, one can produce energy and lose weight without the suggested consumption of carbohydrates, which is the main idea of the diet.
Skov, Toubro, Ronn, Holm, and Astrup (1999) performed a study on weight loss in obese subjects by replacement of carbohydrates by proteins. They found that consumption of higher levels of protein do help obese people lose more weight than when combined with carbohydrates. The researchers mainly observed changes in body weight, body composition, and blood lipid levels. There were two groups of subjects, one with a low protein diet (15% of total intake) and one with a high protein diet (85% of total intake). All food was provided by self-selection and compliance was monitored by urinary nitrogen excretion, which measures the amount of protein in ones diet. All subjects were told to continue their regular daily habits and physical activity, even the consumption of alcohol in moderation and smoking. The researchers found that weight loss in the high protein group was almost twice as much than the high carbohydrate group, which was mainly due to a reduction in body fat mass. Slight improvements in blood lipid levels were also observed in the high protein diet just as the Atkins Center had claimed for type 2 diabetics.
In 1996 a study regarding weight loss with a low or high carbohydrate diet
was done at the Department of Internal Medicine at the University Hospital
in Geneva. Researchers wanted to find a way for obese people to lose
weight and cut the cardiovascular disease risk and keep the weight off.
Golay, Eigenheer, Morel, and Lehmann evaluated the effects of different
composed diets on weight loss and fat loss, and insulin levels were compared
as well.
Each of the two groups studied took in the same amount of calories but
group one took in 25% more carbohydrates than group two. Weight and
body fat percentage were studied in the 68 patients before, during, and
after the 12-week diet program by using skinfold thickness and bioelectrical
impedance. Body weight, body mass index, body fat percentage, and
waist-hip ratio were all similar in all subjects in both prior to the study.
In the end, neither diet proved to be a better means of weight loss.
The fat loss was inferior to the total loss, which means that the loss
of lean body mass was mainly due to protein and water loss. In addition,
insulin levels decreased largely and similarly in both diets.
This study contrasts the claims made by the Atkins Center on what makes
their diet work. They claim that insulin levels are maintained with
a high protein diet therefore decreasing one’s appetite; This study proves
that true, but it also show that a low-protein diet does the same and it
would therefore be unnecessary to cut carbohydrates out of ones diet.
Marckmann, Toubro, and Astrup conducted a study compared the influence
of two different weight loss regimens, one high carbohydrate and one low
carbohydrate. Thirty-six female subjects with an average age of forty-four
were placed into each of the two groups and given a specific diet plan.
Subjects kept a daily nutrition diary to keep track of carbohydrate and
fat consumption and adherence was also monitored by blood and urine tests.
At the end of the study, the researchers found that there was weight lost
among subjects in both groups and therefore no significant difference in
weight loss methods. The study did show that triglyceride levels
were 30% lower in the low carbohydrate dieters than in the high carbohydrate
dieters.
In Conclusion
The Atkins Diet is obviously a good way to lose weight in a short amount of time, but it doesn’t seem to be the best way. Even though it has shown to be helpful to certain aspects of human health, there is question as to what it will provide in the long run. In addition, when a person brings carbohydrates back into their diet after reaching their desired weight, they are required to over-exercise in order to keep the weight off until the body exits ketosis; and a person cannot go their whole life never consuming carbohydrates again. If an obese person is interested in dropping a large amount of weight in a short amount of time, the Atkins diet is the way to go, as long as they are ready to face the repercussions when they complete the diet. Other than that, the best and most healthy way to lose weight is to have a little bit of everything: protein, fruits, vegetables, grains, and even fat. A balanced diet, accompanied by daily physical activity or exercise, is the best way to insure good healthy, steady weight, and body composition.
A Golay, C Eigenheer, Y Morel, P Kujawski, T Lehmann, N de Tonnac. “Weight loss with low or high carbohydrate diet?” International Journal of Obesity (1996) 20, 1067-1072.
Skov, Toubro, Ronn, Holm, Astrup. “Randomized trial on protein vs. carbohydrate in ad libitum fat reduced diet for the treatment of obesity.” International Journal of Obesity and Related Metabolic Disorders 23(5):528-536, May, 1999.
Whitehead, McNeill, Smith. “The effect of protein intake on 24-h energy expenditure during energy restriction.” International Journal of Obesity and Related Metabolic Disorders 20(8): 727-732, Aug, 1996.
Marckmann, Toubro, Astrup. “Sustained improvement in blood lipids, coagulation, and fibrinolysis after major weight loss in obese subject.” European Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 52: 329-333, 1998.
Heilbronn, Noakes, Clifton. “Effect of energy restriction, weight loss, and diet composition on plasma lipids and glucose in patients with type 2 diabetes.” Diabetes Care, 22:889-895, 1999.
http://www.atkinscenter.com/diet101.html
http://www.wfla.com/health/272.htm
http://www4.phys.com/applications/HpyerNews/get/forums/affirm/70.html
|
Psychology DepartmentThe Health Psychology Home Page is
produced and maintained by David Schlundt, PhD. |
|
|
|
Vanderbilt Homepage | Introduction to Vanderbilt | Admissions | Colleges & Schools | Research Centers | News & Media Information | People at Vanderbilt | Libraries | Administrative Departments | Medical |
Return to the Health Psychology Home
Page |
Send E-mail
comments or questions to Dr. Schlundt |
|
Search |
